Shop More Submit  Join Login
About Digital Art / Hobbyist Premium Member MLP-Silver-QuillMale/United States Group :iconclutterstepping: Clutterstepping
 
Recent Activity
Deviant for 2 Years
4 Month Premium Membership
Statistics 135 Deviations 1,830 Comments 601,730 Pageviews

Newest Deviations

Favourites

Activity


After the Fact: Keep Calm and Flutter On by MLP-Silver-Quill
After the Fact: Keep Calm and Flutter On
It was the episode that gave Discord a fresh start. For some, the return of a beloved character and voice actor. For others the ruination of the same.

For me, I'm just gonna try to make it through this without ticking off one of Discords biggest fans!

Hope you enjoy!

Fluttershy`s cottage vector courtesy of :iconioverd:
Loading...
Imani - Part 3 by MLP-Silver-Quill
Imani - Part 3
<=Part 2 | Cover | Part 4

And this is why herbivores should be wary of keeping carnivore pets. Just saying.

If you'd like to know more about Doodle Draw and Freckle, head on over to :icondoodlethedemon89:! Freckle's already bested Clutterstep in a previous match.
 Clutterstep Vs Freckle by DoodleTheDemon89

The Charcoal Brush used in this piece are from :iconwojciechfus:. If you have need of a charcoal brush in Photoshop, this is an excellent tool. I recommend reading the instructions as the instillation differs from the usual method. Cheers!
Loading...
Imani - Part 2 by MLP-Silver-Quill
Imani - Part 2
<=Part 1 | Cover | Part 3=>

Some folks in Part 1 wondered if talky box had escaped Pinkie Pie's affections. Such is not the case yet. So Clutterstep's letter shall serve as our new narration.

Thanks to everyone who greeted this new story with enthusiasm!
Loading...

Donate

MLP-Silver-Quill has started a donation pool!
2,637 / 3,500
Help upgrade my Clutterstep Group to Super Status with a points donation. Thanks in advance!

You must be logged in to donate.
News of the My Little Pony movie set for 2017 has set the fandom into hype mode. Not only does this mean we have a full theatrical release on the horizon, it also implies that the show will continue for at least another two years. Good stuff!

With this announcement comes commentary, and a fellow fan, Rozgar, pointed me towards a Yahoo! Movies article by one Gwynne Watkins. The piece is titled:

A ‘My Little Pony’ Movie Plea: Don’t Forget the Boys

Well now, that sounds intriguing. A plea to remember the male audience that has unexpectedly appeared for this show? Or perhaps a warning on behalf of the brothers dragged into the theater by mom, dad, and sis? What does Ms. Watkins have to say?

Conventional wisdom has it that children’s entertainment with a central male character can cross gender lines, while movies or TV shows with a central female character will appeal only to girls.

Though conventional, I would not describe this as “wisdom.” I dislike the idea that genders must exist separately and can only relate within a bubble. When I look through history, I see a combined efforts of men and women that shaped the world. Both have their strengths, and anyone who says a country or movement was founded by a single gender isn’t looking at the whole story.

Here’s what I hope Hasbro doesn’t do with the My Little Pony movie: I hope it doesn’t add a male lead character for the sole purpose of reeling in boys. There is no reason why boys can’t relate to the existing pony characters.

Oh dear.

I am of two minds on this. Because yes, I do very much identify with Applejack’s values, Fluttershy’s timidity, Rarity’s need for creative expression, and so forth. And I want to emphasis Ms. Watkin’s use of the word, "solely". A male character brought in to be “the boy”. I too cannot stand token characters. If they are not vital to the story, they should not be eating up screen time. It’s why so many comedic sidekicks and useless love interests over cinema history have driven me batty.

Yet there is a second half to that entry that troubles me:

There is no reason why boys can’t relate to the existing pony characters.

Very true, but does that mean male characters needn't to be featured at all? This touches on an issue that’s become more and more prominent as I watch the show and the fandom: is there a place for male characters in this story?

It all comes back to this:

All six of the show’s main characters are female ponies. While a few notable supporting characters are male, the fictional nation of Equestria is predominantly populated by female ponies. For someone like me, who grew up watching ’80s cartoons with one or two token girls, this is very exciting.  

This is the contradiction of the article, and the mentality that I’ve been noticing more and more: Ms. Watkins champions that male audience members can identify with female characters, yet she’s still counting characters by their gender. None of the ponies are “the girl”, yet she doesn’t seem eager to include a character who is “a boy.”

And I do understand the appeal of an all-girl show (with Spike). I grew up watching shows with one or two token female characters, and I can see why there’d be a desire to shift the dynamic and present a more diverse range of female characters so the audience can choose their favorites.

Does that exclude the option of a male character? I’ve seen commentary like this on the net. “A male can’t work with the Mane 6 because this is a girl’s show!” 

I do not understand this fear that featuring a male character working alongside the Mane 6 will somehow undermine their status as likeable characters and role models. That somehow, the presence of a Y chromosome renders the double-X obsolete. Do we truly think so poorly of these characters? Worse still, do women really think so poorly of themselves?

Ms. Watkins goes on to use the heroines of Frozen as an example of a male demographic accepting female leads. I’m not as big a fan of her example because it sounds like we enjoyed Elsa and Anna in spite of the fact they are women. Rather, I think the entire audience liked Elsa, Anna, Hans, and even Olaf because they were all great characters.

And I hope My Little Pony the movie has great characters. Female or male, as long as I like them or love to hate them (like a good villain), I will be pleased.

They can even take a cue from Frozen's marketing department and emphasize humor and goofy sidekicks. Say hello to Spike the Dragon!

Didn’t we already say there shouldn’t be token characters? If Spike’s role is to be the butt of jokes once again, I’ll be very disappointed. Heck, he can be that one male character if he’s as supportive and positive as he was in Equestria Girls.

Featuring a male supporter of the Mane 6 is not a requirement, but what a positive message! To show that boys and girls can work together. That it’s not an all-or-nothing deal.

Because the little girls who watch this show, and the boys watching Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and the like, are going to grow up and have to work together. I’d rather young men and women go into the world with their eyes open. You can cling to the cliques and celebrate single-sex gatherings, yet presenting a world where guys and girls never work together? That’s not just fantasy, that’s delusion. And potentially dangerous to the viewers.  

So what are your thoughts? Would you like to see a stallion help out the Mane 6 in the movie, or perhaps work along side them in the show? Are the Mane 6 enough for the audience? Does a show aimed at girls even need to feature a male character?

deviantID

MLP-Silver-Quill's Profile Picture
MLP-Silver-Quill

Artist | Hobbyist | Digital Art
United States
I became a My Little Pony fan in the latter part of 2011, well into the show's second season. As a latecomer, I'm in a strange situation. The online community is pretty unknown to me, and none of my local friends are fans.

I admire the creativity surrounding MLP, in both the show itself and the creativity of its fans. I created this account to focus my own expressions. Keep checking back and I hope everyone enjoys my drawings!
Interests

Groups

Comments


Add a Comment:
 
:icond-rock92:
D-Rock92 Featured By Owner 16 hours ago  Hobbyist General Artist
Happy Thanksgiving!
Reply
:icontiagamgee11:
TiaGamgee11 Featured By Owner 17 hours ago  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Heyo! How are you?
Reply
:iconjess06:
jess06 Featured By Owner 1 day ago
Just wondering, when you do collabs on Youtube, how do you do so?
Reply
:iconladykittuna:
LadyKittuna Featured By Owner 1 day ago
Do you think you could look over my analysis script?
Reply
:iconmlp-silver-quill:
MLP-Silver-Quill Featured By Owner 1 day ago  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Do you have it on a dropbox or Google drive. If so, please send me the link and I'll try to get to it after Thanksgiving. With the folks, so I can't do anything sooner.
Reply
:iconladykittuna:
LadyKittuna Featured By Owner 1 day ago
Thanks.  I have a Google drive, I'll transfer it to there when I am done.  You are sweetie.
Reply
:iconladykittuna:
LadyKittuna Featured By Owner 2 days ago
Who does the backgrounds for your videos?
Reply
:icontheonenameddj:
theonenamedDJ Featured By Owner 2 days ago
Will there be any new videos from you?
Reply
:iconmlp-silver-quill:
MLP-Silver-Quill Featured By Owner 1 day ago  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Reply
Add a Comment: